Citi / AAdvantage Executive World Elite Mastercard vs. Citi / AAdvantage Globe Mastercard

Citi is an advertising partner.

With these premium American Airlines cards, the choice comes down to lounge access, elite status and statement credits. 

The Citi® / AAdvantage® Executive World Elite Mastercard® and Citi® / AAdvantage® Globe™ Mastercard® both carry high annual fees and benefits largely focused on American Airlines.

The latter is a recently introduced co-branded airline credit card that focuses on statement credits and in-flight experiences, while the former, with unlimited Admirals Club access and the chance to earn points toward elite status, is for frequent travelers who want a boost toward the next status tier. 

However, there are enough differences to set them apart, including annual fees, welcome offers and value for the effort required. Here's everything you need to know about the Citi / AAdvantage Executive World Elite Mastercard vs. Citi / AAdvantage Globe Mastercard.

The Citi / AAdvantage Executive World Elite Mastercard charges a $595 annual fee, while the Citi / AAdvantage Globe Mastercard charges a $350 annual fee. The Citi Globe card is the obvious winner with a smaller annual fee, but don't write the Citi AAdvantage Executive card off until you fully understand all of its benefits. 

With the Citi Executive World Elite, you can earn 70,000 American Airlines AAdvantage® bonus miles after spending $7,000 in purchases within the first three months of account opening.

Compare that with the Citi Globe card, which offers for a limited time, 90,000 American Airlines AAdvantage® bonus miles after $5,000 in purchases in the first four months of account opening.

You can earn a bigger welcome bonus with the Citi Executive World Elite, but you'll have to spend $3,000 more in the same three-month time period.

With the Citi Executive World Elite card, you'll earn: 

• 4X miles on eligible American Airlines purchases and 5X miles once you spend $150,000 on the card in a calendar year for the remainder of the year
• 10X miles on eligible hotels booked through aadvantagehotels.com and on eligible car rentals booked through aadvantagecars.com
• 1X miles on all other purchases

And with the Citi Globe card, you'll earn: 

• 3X miles on eligible American Airlines purchases 
• 6X miles on AAdvantage Hotels™ bookings
• 2X miles at restaurants, including takeout and delivery, and on eligible Rides and Rails™ transit purchases, including taxis, rideshares and public transit
• 1X miles on all other purchases

Compared to the Globe card, the Executive World Elite earns an additional mile per dollar spent on American Airlines (and 2 additional miles once you spend $150,000 in a calendar year). However, the Citi Globe features more bonus categories, covering restaurants, taxis, rideshares and public transit. The base rate for both cards is 1 mile per dollar spent. 

Although you'll earn 10X miles on hotels and car rentals booked through American Airlines with the Citi Executive World Elite and 6X miles on eligible AAdvantage Hotels™ bookings with the Citi Globe, these rewards rates are only valuable if you don’t care about earning hotel elite status. Third-party bookings aren’t eligible to earn elite status credit or bonus points toward a hotel loyalty program. 

If this isn’t a deal-breaker for you, then the Citi Executive card is more rewarding. But assuming hotel elite status is important to you, the Citi Globe card has more robust everyday spending categories. Over the course of a year, the Globe card is likely more useful for most people. 

In terms of rewards redemption options, both cards are equally valuable; you'll earn American AAdvantage miles and Loyalty Points with either card. Both cards also allow you to earn elite status without flying and offer the same redemption options for your miles. 

Typically, long-haul international award flights with American Airlines' partners present the most value, mile per mile, but you can also redeem miles for hotel stays, car rentals and other travel booked through American. 

American’s partner airlines include:

• Air Tahiti Nui
• Alaska Airlines
• British Airways
• Cape Air
• Cathay Pacific
• China Southern Airlines
• Etihad Airways
• Fiji Airways
• Finnair
• GOL Airlines
• Hawaiian Airlines
• Iberia
• Japan Airlines
• JetSMART
• Malaysia Airlines
• Qantas Airways
• Qatar Airways
• Royal Air Maroc
• Royal Jordanian Airlines
• SriLankan Airlines

If you’re flush with miles, you can also use miles for upgrades on American or Qantas, merchandise and lounge passes, but these are often a low-value proposition. Your best bet is to use American miles for award flights, and both cards offer this option. 

Both of these American Airlines credit cards carry high annual fees. However, the Citi Executive World Elite features more straightforward benefits (the main one being access to Admirals Club lounges), while the Citi Globe requires you to track your credits.

Lounge access

With the Citi Executive World Elite, you get unlimited access to nearly every Admirals Club location around the world. If you were to purchase an Admirals Club® membership, you’d pay up to $850 for an individual membership — so receiving access through a $595-annual-fee card is a significant discount.

Plus, you can bring your spouse or domestic partner, children under 18 or up to two guests traveling with you. If you use this benefit frequently, it could easily justify holding the card long-term. 

The Citi Globe offers four Admirals Club passes per calendar year. You can redeem them for yourself or guests over 18, plus up to three children per redeemed pass. Considering one-day passes can cost $79 each, receiving and using all four passes can eat up a significant portion of the card’s $350 annual fee. But with no guest access (other than children), you can blow through these passes in just a visit or two. 

In terms of lounge access, the Globe card is helpful if you travel occasionally (and sometimes bring a kiddo or two with you), or if you want to have a lounge pass on hand for a trip here and there. While we don't recommend getting the Globe card solely for the airport lounge passes, it’s a nice perk that can add value in conjunction with the card’s statement credits and earning power. 

Statement credits

Both cards feature statement credits you can use to further offset the annual fee. In the case of the Citi Globe card, you’ll need to make use of these credits if you want to recover the card’s annual fee (especially in the first year). 

The Citi Executive World Elite offers a handful of statement credits: 

• Up to $120 toward Global Entry or TSA PreCheck application fees every four years
• 25% credit for in-flight food and beverage purchases on American Airlines flights
• Up to $120 in Grubhub credits ($10 per billing cycle) every 12 months
• Up to $120 in credits each calendar year for prepaid car rentals booked directly with Avis and Budget
• Up to $120 in Lyft credits (up to $10 per month) when you take three eligible rides per month

Of course, these credits are only useful if you shop with or use these particular merchants. If you prefer to rent cars elsewhere or don’t use Lyft, for example, the credits become useless. As for the Global Entry or TSA PreCheck credit, this benefit is available on nearly every premium credit card these days. 

The Citi Globe features even more statement credits: 

• Up to $120 toward Global Entry or TSA PreCheck application fees every four years
• Up to $100 for in-flight purchases on American Airlines flights made with your card
• Up to $240 annually for Turo trips (up to $30 for each eligible and completed trip)*
• Up to $100 back per calendar year for purchases at your choice of up to two of these brands: 1stDibs, eligible AAdvantage Hotels™ bookings, Future Personal Training, Live Nation (exclusions apply)

*To qualify, you must link your card to your Turo account on Turo.com/Globe and pay for the trip with your card.

The $100 credit for in-flight purchases could be useful for purchasing meals or treating your group to a round of drinks, but the other credits are only as useful as you make them. If you don’t shop at the given brands and have to go out of your way to use the credits, it may be more of an inconvenience than a benefit — especially if you have to overspend just to use the credits. In some cases, the services may not be available in your area, and if you have to make the extra effort, you may find the credits just aren’t worth it. 

On the flip side, if you already rent from Turo or buy event tickets from Live Nation, for example, you might see these credits as an easy source of savings throughout the year. The choice is entirely dependent on whether you’ll use the credits, and don’t forget to factor in the time and mental effort required to track them. 

Additional perks

The Citi Executive World Elite and Citi Globe both do an excellent job of providing benefits proportional to their annual fee and intended cardholder. The Citi Executive is ideal for frequent American flyers, while the Citi Globe card offers enough perks to entice casual flyers to choose American.

With the Citi Executive World Elite, you’ll also get:

• Priority check-in, screening and boarding when flying with American Airlines
• First checked bag free on domestic American Airlines itineraries for you and up to eight travel companions on the same reservation
• No foreign transaction fees
• Up to 20,000 extra Loyalty Points: 10,000 bonus points when you reach 50,000 in a qualification year and another 10,000 when you reach 90,000 in the same qualification year

If you check bags when you fly or want a boost toward the next elite status tier, these extras can be worth their weight in gold. Plus, priority boarding can be a great asset, especially when you need overhead bin space on full flights. 

If you can make use of the Citi Executive's benefits and added perks, in addition to the lounge access, you can easily cover the card’s annual fee many times over. 

The Citi Globe card is no slouch in terms of extra benefits, either. You’ll get: 

• Preferred boarding when flying with American Airlines (for you and up to eight companions traveling with you on the same reservation)
• First checked bag free on domestic American Airlines itineraries for you and up to eight travel companions on the same reservation
• No foreign transaction fees
• Flight Streak™ bonus: Earn 5,000 Loyalty Points for every four qualifying American Airlines flights, up to 15,000 extra Loyalty Points per qualification year
• American Airlines Companion Certificate starting the second year of card membership: Pay $99 plus taxes and fees for a qualifying round-trip domestic flight in the main cabin for a companion when you renew your card

These benefits are designed to incentivize you to fly with American, and they may make an American flight worth choosing over a competitor's. 

It’s worth noting that both cards also offer: 

• Trip cancellation and interruption protection
• Trip delay protection
• Lost baggage protection
• Rental car insurance

Most premium travel credit cards offer these benefits, but it’s good to know you have some recourse if your travel plans start going sideways. 

If you fly American often and value elite status and lounge access, choose the Citi Executive World Elite card. The benefits you’ll receive are well worth it for frequent travelers seeking lounge access and a boost toward the next elite status tier. 

If you fly American occasionally but often enough that benefits like a bonus lounge pass, priority boarding and in-flight purchases would make you more comfortable, the Citi Global card is a better option. There’s an annual fee to contend with, so be sure it’s worthwhile either in American benefits or useful statement credits. 

Your decision will likely come down to whether you want lounge access or prefer multiple benefits that add up over the year. 

At CNBC Select, our mission is to provide our readers with high-quality service journalism and comprehensive consumer advice so they can make informed decisions with their money. Every credit card comparison is based on rigorous reporting by our team of expert writers and editors. While CNBC Select earns a commission from affiliate partners on many offers and links, we create all our content without input from our commercial team or any outside third parties, and we pride ourselves on our journalistic standards and ethics.

Catch up on CNBC Select's in-depth coverage of credit cards, banking and money, and follow us on TikTok, Facebook, Instagram and Twitter to stay up to date.

Information about the Citi® / AAdvantage® Globe™ Mastercard® has been collected independently by Select and has not been reviewed or provided by the issuer of the card prior to publication.